REVENGE the oldest obsession?
Updated: Nov 15

There was a story in the family, part biographical and part apocryphal, regarding my paternal grandfather. As a young boy in the mining valleys of South Wales he was reportedly set upon by a group of squaddies and given a sound beating. You grew up fast back then. Bill was working down the pits by the age of fourteen, and when the regiment returned he was waiting. Five years had gone by. His former assailants probably didn’t even recognise the young man who approached them while they were enjoying some R & R at the village fair …and beat the living daylights out of them.
My grandfather’s image peered back at me through the years this week, complete with flexi-nose (after several breaks) and floret ears (not quite the full cauliflower). It was triggered by not one but two references to that multi-millennial staple of The Business of Pleasure, Revenge, in my audiobook listening: a line in Jo Nesbø’s fourth Harry Hole book, appropriately entitled Nemesis, and the title of Craig Johnson’s first Longmire novel, The Cold Dish.*
Neither of these two giants of the crime genre had had much hands-on knowledge of the state-funded arm of the Revenge-Biz, aka the criminal justice system (Nesbø had been a successful stockbroker and singer-songwriter before reaching for the Agatha Christie-inspired quill, while Johnson had served as a security officer at a Manhattan museum before saddling up for Wyoming) and frankly, neither of them needed to; the thing about Revenge stories is that they strike a note in (almost) all of us, across countries and cultures, centuries and millennia, no matter what temperature it is served at. Indeed, where would Nesbø and Johnson’s classical counterparts have been without their drachma-spinning revenge sagas?
ITEM: Aeschylus, The Oresteia (458 BC) not for the faint-hearted or lovers of pies. ITEM: Euripides, Medea (431 BC) seldom found in the Top Ten Thousand parenting manuals.
ITEM: Sophocles Electra (~5th Century BC) so far-reaching a revenge formula that Jung, the Swiss super-shrink, named an entire complex after it.
While the Elizabethan Chapter of The Business of Pleasure also knew when they were onto a good thing (good bad thing?).
Thomas Kyd, The Spanish Tragedy (late 1580s) — one of the most popular and frequently performed plays of the period. It featured a grieving-to-the-point-of-madness central character, a play-within-a-play and a ghost … sound familiar?
Yep … Shakespeare, Hamlet (1600–1601) — over 30,000 words compared to the roughly 23,000 words of Kyd's philosophy-light(er) Spanish Tragedy.
Not to mention Middleton’s The Revenger’s Tragedy, Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi and Ford’s ’Tis Pity She’s a Whore, which had playhouse audiences baying for (and paying for) on-stage retribution.
So why is it really only the poets and playwrights, novelists and screenwriters of The Business of Pleasure who have made an in depth study of this phenomenally long-lived obsession? As one 2019 scientific paper puts it:
‘...The historical lack of research on revenge is surprising, not only because stories of revenge are so intriguing, but also because revenge is remarkably common and takes a serious toll on society. A 2012 study by the New York Police Department found that 42% of the city’s murders stemmed from revenge (New York City Police Dep. 2012). Across the United States, revenge is implicated in as many as 61% of school shootings and 27% of bombings (Bur. Alcohol. Tob. Firearms 1999, Vossekuil et al. 2002). This is not only a pattern found in the United States. Revenge is a global phenomenon. It is implicated as a casual factor in many homicides worldwide (Daly and Wilson 1988, Kopsaj 2016). Historical cross-cultural analyses have uncovered evidence of vengeful feuds or individual acts of vengeance in 90% of contemporary and traditional societies around the world (Ericksen & Horton 1992).’ **
Before asking the 64 Billion Drachma Question: ‘Did Revenge Biologically Evolve?
‘...According to some theories, revenge evolved during the Pleistocene Era -the time frame in which the Ice Age occurred and human anatomy developed into what it is today. One forerunning evolutionary theory of revenge was outlined by McCullough and colleagues (2013); see also Sell et al., 2009). Their biological model suggests that aspects of early human history contributed to the genetic evolution of revenge. In particular, it points out that our evolutionary predecessors faces a number of adaptive problems – including murder, theft, and mate-poaching- that threatened their survival and reproduction. The best way for these early humans to escape such threats was to fight fire with fire -responding in kind to aggressive threats. In this sense, revenge evolved primarily as a deterrence mechanism, alerting potential antagonists to think twice before harming a victim again and ensuring that avengers would not be repeatedly cheated or attacked.’
Revenge might just be an exclusively human phenomenon, as the great Jo Nesbø suggests through his fictional psychiatrist, Ståle Aune, in the novel Nemesis:
“Did you know that humans are the only living creatures to practice revenge?”
And it might well be that many of the more enlightened 21st Century humans might concur with Walt Longmire’s concluding sentiment in the epilogue of The Cold Dish:
“It wasn’t that revenge was a dish best served cold, it was a dish best not served at all,”
But bearing in mind that the Pleistocene spanned from 2.58 million to 11,700 years ago (or roughly 103,200 Grandads) I think this is one dish that won’t fall off the menu any time soon.
DT
13 November 2026
*While the phrase ‘Revenge is a dish best served cold’ ‘ has variously found fame on the lips of Don Corleone in Mario Puzo’s The Godfather and as an ‘old Klingon proverb’ in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, it first saw the light of (human) day in Eugène Sue’s 1841 novel Mathilde: Mémoires d’une jeune femme.
**Revenge: A Multilevel Review and Synthesis Joshua Conrad Jackson, Virginia K. Choi and Michele J. Gelfand Annual Review of Psychology, 2019



Comments